Blending urban minimalism and nonchalant chic, a mandarin collar shirt is the perfect alternative to the standard collar type. However, not being your everyday choice, you might be wondering if the collar should be worn buttoned or not.
In terms of style, when a dressier look is what you’re after, you might want to wear the collar buttoned, especially if your look includes a suit or sport coat. Even if the outfit is casual, as in including jeans and athletic shoes, buttoning up the shirt collar will result in a sharper, more urban look.
On the other hand, if what you’re after is a softer and casual look, regardless of whether the shirt is worn with formal or casual pieces and especially if it’s a hot summer day, just leave the collar button undone.
In addition to your desired look, consider also the visual effect of each option on your face shape. Which of the two options complements it most?
The mandarin collar, being so minimalist, tends to accentuate one’s face shape, offering little to the wearer to visually balance his face’s proportions. For example, a man whose face shape is round or square, especially if his hair is cut very short or is bald, by wearing the (mandarin) collar buttoned, will only emphasise his face’s width. What he needs is to add visual length, which makes the face appear less wide and more oval, and for this, the collar should be worn unbuttoned.
The opposite applies for men whose face is oblong-shaped and who therefore, need to visually minimise its length. Although a mandarin collar will not add visual width in the same way a standard collar does, leaving the collar button fastened will avoid adding even more depth below the face. A higher collar can also help here, as it visually shortens the neck.
Being well-dressed is not just about putting together a stylish outfit but also about how well that outfit complements your shape and features. Next time you’re trying on a shirt, consider how much it flatters (or not) your face shape. Does it accentuate it or make it look more balanced? Of course, other elements usually also come into play, such as one’s haircut and beard shape. These should also balance/complement one’s face shape for more flattering results.